Bookmarks

    Nothing saved yet. Use the bookmark on any article. Bookmarks are kept on this device only: they stay private and work without an account.

    Settings

    Appearance

    Reading mode

    Font size

    Content width

    Line spacing

    Keyboard shortcuts

    /
    Search
    j k
    Next / previous story
    ← →
    Previous / next section (columns)
    b
    Bookmarks
    s
    Settings
    r
    Columns / scroll
    t
    Light / dark

    Saved in this browser only.

    Ping2Prompt
    Subscribe to the Weekly Brief Sign in
    The entrance to Meta's headquarters in Menlo Park, with a sign reading Meta, 1 Hacker Way beside a road and traffic lights.

    Meta says WhatsApp encryption order under Canada's Bill C-22 is a red line

    Meta and Signal say they would resist orders under Canada's Bill C-22 that undermine encryption. The government says the bill does not allow backdoors.

    Meta AI

    What changed

    Meta says it would refuse any order under Canada's Bill C-22 that weakened encryption on services such as WhatsApp, and would look at all available options if served one. Rachel Curran, Meta Canada's public policy head, said such an order is "a red line for us". The National Post reports that Meta says those options include pulling WhatsApp from Canada, though the text available to us is truncated.

    The Senate is discussing the bill. Curran and Signal's Udbhav Tiwari were due to give evidence to its National Security committee on the Monday after the Globe article ran.

    What it does

    Per The Globe and Mail, the bill would require electronic service providers, including messaging apps, to change their systems on government request to give police and CSIS spying capabilities. If it passes, the public safety minister could issue orders to companies operating in Canada, and the companies would have to keep those orders secret.

    Companies could also be forced to retain customer metadata for up to six months, cut from 12 months by an amendment earlier this year. That metadata would exclude emails, web-browsing history, social-media activity and text messages. It could include which phone numbers have been in contact and location-pinpointing data.

    What is verified

    Nothing here is independently verified. These are positions, all as reported by the Globe.

    • Meta's claims: Curran says Meta does not currently collect such metadata, that a retention rule would create a surveillance database and a target for hackers, and that weakened security could affect U.S. users.
    • Government: a spokesperson for Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree says the bill does not permit or compel backdoors, and cites an amendment saying no obligation under the Act requires decrypting end-to-end encrypted information.
    • Signal: it told the Globe in May it would withdraw from Canada if asked to compromise user privacy. Tiwari says the June amendments do not change that.
    • Apple precedent: Curran pointed to Apple pulling its advanced end-to-end encryption service from the UK after a similar order on encrypted cloud backups. That is Meta's account.

    What it means for you

    If you run messaging, backup or other hosted services with users in Canada, follow the Senate study. Once the final text is out, check whether your service would count as an electronic service provider and what the metadata retention rule would require of you.

    What the sources don't cover

    We have no bill text or government statement, only a ministerial spokesperson's paraphrase of the encryption amendment. There is no Senate vote timeline, no hearing date, and no independent legal or technical analysis of whether the bill could compel weaker encryption.

    Sources

    Image: LPS.1, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons


    This story was produced with AI assistance from the sources listed above and fact-checked against them before publication. Read our editorial methodology and the corrections log. Spotted an error? Email [email protected].

    Continue

    Share on Bluesky · Mastodon · Email ·

    Discussion